The Devil Is in the Details…or the Drums…or…Everything? How High-Control Religion Creates Spiritual Paranoia

Recently, during an Instagram scroll sesh, I came across a post that rattled me. Which, given the state of the world, isn’t exactly rare these days. But this one hit differently—it was from someone who’s all-in at a large evangelical megachurch here in town.

(You might be wondering why I still follow people like this. Honestly? I’ve blocked plenty of accounts over the years that felt too triggering. But there are a few people from my former world I stay connected to—partly to keep my feed from becoming an echo chamber, and partly to keep tabs on what’s trending in the world of high-control religion.)

The post said:

“The devil is not afraid of many of today’s ‘worship songs.’ He probably wrote some of them. He is afraid of the Word of God.”

For whatever reason, this post snapped me out of my scrolling stupor. It had been a while since I’d reflected on the spiritual paranoia I was raised in—but this brought it rushing back.

Because here’s the thing: when you’re taught that the devil could be anywhere—even hiding in something that looks or feels holy—you end up living in a constant state of fear. You learn to be suspicious of anything that feels good, comforting, or creative. You have to always be on guard, because Satan is always trying to trick you.

I remember being in high school when evangelical churches started preaching that secular music was dangerous—maybe even demonic. The logic? If the song wasn’t written to glorify God, it was probably glorifying the devil. Friends were tossing their CD collections and repenting for listening to Top 40 radio.

And me? Feeling anxious that Satan might be lurking in my Oasis and Smashing Pumpkins albums, I reluctantly jumped on the bandwagon. I didn’t really want to—but hey, you could never be too careful.

What I didn’t realize at the time was this: that fear wasn’t making me more spiritual.
It was making me hypervigilant.
It was making me afraid.

The Devil Could Be Anywhere

In high-control religion, fear isn’t just a byproduct—it’s a tool. And few things are more fear-inducing than the idea that Satan might be hiding in plain sight.

I was taught that the devil could show up in anything that wasn’t explicitly “of God.” Music, books, movies, yoga, emotions, curiosity, your own intuition—any of it could be a gateway for spiritual deception. The message was clear: you couldn’t trust anything unless it had a Christian label. Even then, you had to stay suspicious.

This wasn’t framed as fear-mongering—it was framed as wisdom and faithfulness. We were told to be spiritually discerning, to “test every spirit,” and to stay vigilant. But when the threshold for what counts as “demonic” is constantly shifting, you’re left in a permanent state of spiritual hypervigilance.

That fear doesn’t just stay in the youth group or Sunday sermon. It shapes how you think, how you make decisions, and how safe you feel in your own mind.

Common effects I see in religious trauma survivors include:

  • Second-guessing your gut

  • Anxiety in situations that should feel calm

  • Feeling guilty for joy, curiosity, or rest

  • Fear that asking questions means you’re backsliding

  • Believing your own voice can’t be trusted

What gets called “discernment” in high-control religion often functions more like spiritual anxiety.

Because if even worship songs might be demonic, when is it safe to relax?

Hypervigilance Isn’t Holiness—It’s a Trauma Response

Inside high-control religion, hypervigilance gets spiritualized. Constant suspicion is considered a sign of spiritual maturity. Fear is framed as discernment. Anxiety becomes a sign of the presence of evil.

But through a trauma-informed lens? That’s not faithfulness—that’s survival.

Hypervigilance is what your nervous system does when it’s learned that danger could strike at any moment. In high-control religious systems, that danger often takes the shape of demonic deception, a sinful thought, or your “untrustworthy” heart leading you astray.

So you stay on guard.
You monitor your emotions.
You fear your curiosity.
You scrutinize your joy.

This constant internal monitoring is exhausting—and it gets mistaken for spiritual obedience. But it doesn’t create peace. It creates anxiety.

It teaches your body that rest, pleasure, creativity, and intuition are risky. It disconnects you from your own internal wisdom.

And perhaps most painfully and alarmingly: the fear doesn’t feel irrational.
It feels holy.
It feels like protection.
But really? It’s fear.
Conditioned fear—dressed up as devotion.

What This Kind of Fear Steals From You

When you're always watching your back for the devil, it's nearly impossible to be present in your own life. Spiritual hypervigilance doesn’t just leave you tired—it chips away at the most life-giving parts of being human.

Here’s what this kind of fear costs:

  • Joy starts to feel dangerous. If something feels too good, you wonder if it’s a trap.

  • Curiosity gets shut down. Asking “why” or “what if” starts to feel like rebellion.

  • Pleasure becomes suspect. If it feels good, it must be sinful.

  • Stillness feels unsafe. Silence makes space for doubt, so you fill it with noise.

  • Self-trust is replaced by fear. You were taught your heart is “deceitful,” so you stop listening.

  • Creativity gets stifled. Unless it can be explicitly labeled “Christian,” it’s risky.

  • Rest becomes impossible. If you’re not striving, you’re vulnerable.

High-control religion doesn’t just affect what you believe—it affects your ability to feel safe inside your own body. And when fear is spiritualized, it’s hard to recognize it as fear. It just feels like being a “good Christian.”

What If the Devil Isn’t Everywhere?

Let’s just sit with this for a second:

What if the devil isn’t lurking behind every drumbeat, lyric, or quiet moment of joy?
What if the things you were taught to fear are actually just part of normal human existence?

If you were raised to see the world as a spiritual battleground, it makes sense that everything feels like a test. That joy feels suspicious. That safety feels too good to trust.

But what if that framework wasn’t about protecting you—it was about controlling you?

When everything is spiritual warfare:

  • Your joy becomes collateral damage.

  • Your rest feels undeserved.

  • Your intuition is silenced.

  • Your healing feels like rebellion.

But here’s the truth: you’re allowed to question those fear-based teachings.
You’re allowed to trust your body.
You’re allowed to feel peace without suspecting it’s a trap.

You don’t need to spiritualize your fear to make it valid.
You don’t need to earn your safety by staying anxious.
You’re allowed to build a life where peace is a core value worth protecting.

You’re Not Broken—You Were Trained to Be Afraid

If you’ve lived with a constant fear of being deceived...
If you’ve questioned your joy or your intuition because it didn’t align with what you were taught...
If you’ve been afraid of music, rest, art, or your own emotions...

You are not broken.

You were trained to be afraid.

Your nervous system adapted to a world that spiritualized fear.
You learned that vigilance was safety.
That obedience meant suspicion.
That trust—in yourself or the world—was dangerous.

So if it’s hard to let go of the fear now? That makes sense.
You’re not failing at healing.
You’re slowly, bravely, unlearning something that was never meant to be yours.

You deserve a spirituality that doesn’t make you afraid to be human.

Ready to Begin Unlearning Spiritual Fear?

If this post resonates, you’re not alone—and you don’t have to navigate it alone either.

I help survivors of religious trauma and spiritual abuse rebuild trust with themselves, their bodies, and their sense of meaning. I offer therapy in California, Florida, and Missouri—and I’d be honored to support your healing.

Next
Next

When Faith Tells You Your Feelings Are a Problem: Untangling Emotional Shame from Religious Trauma